South African Military History Society

CAPE TOWN BRANCH
NEWSLETTER NO. 285 - JANUARY 2002

Seen from the British viewpoint, the general strategic situation in 1941 was rather gloomy. Britain and her Commonwealth stood alone against the Axis powers, who controlled almost all of Europe. In North Africa Rommel pushed forward. Malta was under siege, and in other parts of the Mediterranean and elsewhere, the British were not doing too well.

On the other hand the Axis land powers were on the up and the campaign against British merchant shipping in the Atlantic went quite successfully. Britain desperately needed almost everything in raw materials and finished war goods, all of which had to come by sea, compelling the Germans to sink as many ships as possible carrying war supplies.

In order to protect their merchant ships against the newly formed U-Boat wolf packs, the British introduced a convoy system whereby ships sailed in groups, defended, albeit insufficiently, by their own guns or a destroyer or two. These were U-Boats' happy times.

Air cover for these convoys was sketchy at first, and strike aircraft sent against the U-Boats at sea or in harbour were also lacking. Carriers only arrived on the scene in 1942/43.

Apart from their U-Boat successes, the Germans had some luck with Luftwaffe aircraft, but even more with surface raiders in the South Atlantic and Indian Oceans. However, the battleships had only made a few casual sorties so far, but it was easy to imagine what damage such force could inflict on big convoys escorted by a few outdated corvettes.

Graf Spee had scuttled herself in South America in 1940. The Deutschland, renamed Luetzow, had been unsuccessful: but on the plus side, Scheer had sunk AMC Jervis Bay and 16 ships, Hipper 7 ships, and Scharnhorst and Gneisenau, under command of Admiral Luetjens, 22 ships altogether.

The German Navy had been ordered to attack convoys but not to tangle with heavy ships in case they suffered damage which could not be repaired at sea. Did this directive come from Hitler, who was a master at land-based warfare but totally unfamiliar with naval strategy?

In 1941, the Royal Navy set up Home Fleet, based at Scapa Flow, consisting of King George V, Hood, Nelson, Rodney and Repulse, and later on Prince of Wales, and there were a number of other warships, most of them old and requiring an update. The Germans had five modern, powerful ships, plus Tirpitz nearing completion.

But we now turn to the Bismarck. Commissioned in August 1940, her captain was Ernst Lindemann, a gunnery expert. She was the largest and most powerful warship in the world, fast, and very well armed. She had 8 x 380 mm guns with a range of 36 km.

The German Seekriegsleitung under Adm Raeder decided to strike a powerful blow against allied convoys by executing operation Rhein using Bismarck and the cruiser Prinz Eugen. They were to break into the North Atlantic to attack convoys.

Bismarck sailed on 19 May 1941 from its base at Gotunhafun with Prinz Eugen and was spotted by Swedish observers and next day a shadowing Swedish cruiser reported their course. This report was sent on to London. The ships turned into Skaggerak, passed the Norwegian coast, and on 21 May arrived just south of Bergen.

In the meantime V.Adm Holland with Hood and Prince of Wales prepared to sail to engage the German ships, with Adm Tovey and the rest of Home Fleet following.

While Prinz Eugen topped up her fuel tanks, Bismarck did not, a serious error of judgement. There was an oiler one day's steaming to the north, but in a critical situation one day can mean the difference between victory and defeat.

There were five access passages from the North Sea into the Atlantic, and on 22/23 May, Luetjens headed for the Denmark Straits and struck heavy seas and thick fog. At 1900 a lookout from the cruiser Suffolk, patrolling the Straits, spotted the big ships and reported. Consequently Tovey and Holland sailed on a converging course, and on 24 May battle commenced.

The first victim was Hood which was straddled by Bismarck's guns, with one hit setting off the magazines, blowing her up. Next was Prince of Wales which received hits from both German ships and was forced to retire.

But Bismarck itself had not escaped unscathed. She had received a number of hits, was down at the bow and listed to port, but she had also lost precious oil, and so Luetjens decided to head for western France. Followed by her pursuers, the German ship became the target of Victorious and her 8 Swordfish, one of which scored a torpedo hit without serious damage.

On 25 May Bismarck limped for the Bay of Biscay, the enemy in pursuit, and on 26 May her fate was sealed. Ark Royal sent two strikes of Swordfish causing more damage, the ship's steering jammed, and next day, when Rodney and King George hammered away with guns and torpedoes, the scuttling order was given.

She sunk at 1936, either by scuttling or by the weight of explosives received. Of her crew of 2 400 only 115 were saved. The Captain and the Admiral went down with their ship.

With Bismarck gone, Scharnhorst and Gneisenau damaged by bombs and under repair, Luetzow torpedoed on 12 June, and Tirpitz still working up, the threat of heavy ships attacking convoys had receded, and Home fleet, with its five battleships, could turn to other duties.

Bob's well researched and expertly presented talk was greatly appreciated, and the applause well deserved. He gave special thanks to Johan v.d.Berg, who once again supplied outstanding overheads and Mac Bissett for his extensive literary support.

The complete text of Bob's talk can be borrowed from the scribe.


FORTHCOMING LECTURES:

17 January 2002
THE GUERILLA WAR IN THE CAPE COLONY DURING THE ANGLO/BOER WAR - PART 2. With emphasis on the career of Commandant Gideon Scheepers
(19 Jan is the Centenary of his execution.)
Illustrated Talk by Rodney Constantine
14 February 2002
THE REBELLION OF 1914
Illustrated Talk by Prof Rodney Davenport
14 March 2002
THE FIRST PHASE OF THE SOUTH AFRICAN MILITARY INVASION OF GERMAN SOUTH WEST AFRICA Sept/Oct 1914
Illustrated Talk by Rodney Warwick
11 April 2002
1. ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING
2. The making of A TOURIST GUIDE TO THE ANGLO/BOER WAR 1899-1902
Talk by Tony Westby-Nunn
3. If time permits: - A short slide presentation on the German FLIEGERTRUPPE AND ZEPPELINS 1910-1918
by John Mahncke
9 May 2002
CAPE FIELD ARTILLERY IN ANGOLA
Illustrated Talk by Col Lionel Crook
13 June 2002
OPERATIONS OF V-FORCE IN ARAKAN/SOUTHWEST
BURMA 1942/43 (Japanese occupied territory).
Illustrated Talk by Richard "Dickie" Bullen
11 July
GALLIPOLI: 1914-1916
Illustrated Talk by Robin Smith
9 August
THE WW 2 GERMAN U-BOOT COMMANDER WHO SHOPPED AT STUTTAFORDS and other legends?
Illustrated Talk by John Mahncke

BOOK CORNER:
THE ROYAL NAVY IN SOUTH AFRICA, 1900-2000.
by Bill Rice, published by Maritime Books, Lodge Hill, obtainable from Simon's Town Museum, tel.: (021) 796 3046. This book is a photograph album of 125 pp, providing a pictorial record of the Royal Navy ships serving in South African waters.

THE KNYSNA CASTAWAYS, by Ian Uys, author of 14 books on South African military history and Delville Wood. This faction book traces the military and political history of the Western Cape between 1790-1880. Obtainable from Johan v.d.Berg 092 5790386.

COVOS DAY BOOKS have sent us their 2001 Catalogue. 2nd edition with new and interesting titles. Anyone wishing to know more is asked to contact Johan v.d.Berg or the Scribe.


INTERLUDE IN SWITZERLAND, the story of the South African refugee-soldier in the Alps during WW II by Paul Schamberger. To order please contact by e-mail: pscham@wol.co.za


GERRY DE VRIES, co-author of: The Muzzle Loading Cannon of South Africa, is also publishing a Newsletter for his CANNON RESEARCH PROJECT. Contact via e-mail: noongun@mweb.co.za



THE CHAVONNE BATTERY, reconstructed at the Waterfront Clock Tower Centre can now be viewed. The open-air-section shows three cannon, one each of 18 pd, 24 pd and 36 pd. When this is connected to the one under the BoE building, it will show an important piece of Cape Town's military history.


CASTLE MILITARY MUSEUM FOUNDATION:
During the recent Trustee meeting, Adv. Dave Mitchell stepped down as Chairman after a long and successful term, due to heavy business commitments. In his place Cmdr Gerry de Vries was elected. Newsletter No. 02/01 is available from the Museum. It contains valuable information and advice.


MILITARY HERITAGE TRAIL:
Cecil Graham reports that negotiations are currently taking place beween two Cape Town organisations to establish a military trail. The route will include the Castle, eight military historical-sites in Cape Town, on Robben Island, Kloof Nek and along the scenic coastal road to Apostle Battery and Hout Bay. From there it will continue over Constantia Nek to Muizenberg, Kalk Bay, Simon's Town and thru the reserve to Cape Point. There are 214 cannons and guns, ranging from 12 pdrs to 9.2", to be seen on this route. A number of them have been preserved and restored to the point of being able to fire.


For 2002 there are a number of meetings, exhibitions as well as celebrations planned by our Museums and Military/History Associations in Simon's Town, Ysterplaat, Cape Town and the Western Cape. This Newsletter will provide further details as and when they become available.


Meetings are normally held on the 2nd Thursday of each month, with the EXCEPTION OF JANUARY, at 20h00 in the Recreation Hall of the SA LEGION'S ROSEDALE COMPLEX, Lower Nursery Road, Rosebank (off Alma Road), opposite Rosebank Railway Station. All visitors welcome. Tea and biscuits will be served.

WE WISH ALL OUR MEMBERS AND FRIENDS A HAPPY, HEALTHY, PEACEFUL AND PROSPEROUS 2002.

Jochen (John) Mahncke (Vice-Chairman/Scribe) (021) 797 5167


South African Military History Society / military.history@rapidttp.com